Welcome to Reino’s Pizza & Pasta
At Reino’s Pizza & Pasta, we bring Italian tradition to Tiffin, OH. Our story began with a passion for serving delicious, authentic cuisine in a welcoming environment. With a menu that boasts an extensive variety of pizzas, pasta, and hearty subs, every dish is crafted to delight the senses. Renowned for our friendly service and vibrant atmosphere, we cater to families, groups, and anyone in search of comfort food. Customers rave about our thin-crust pizzas and creamy Alfredo, all complemented by a full bar. Join us for a meal that feels like a family gathering; at Reino’s, every dining experience is a cherished memory.
-
73 E Market St Tiffin, OH 44883 United States Hotline: (419) 447-5891
Welcome to Reino’s Pizza & Pasta, a delightful Italian eatery nestled in the heart of Tiffin, Ohio. Located at 73 E Market St, this charming spot has become a local favorite for its hearty portions, friendly atmosphere, and deliciously executed dishes. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick lunch, indulging in dinner with family, or catching up with friends, Reino’s offers a casual yet vibrant dining experience.
One of the standout features of Reino’s is its extensive menu, which beautifully showcases both pizza and pasta. From mouthwatering thin-crust pizzas to rich and savory pastas, diners are sure to find something that tantalizes their taste buds. Customers rave about the generous portion sizes and the freshness of the ingredients. As one patron, Brian C., noted, "the service was excellent," and he couldn’t wait to return to explore more options during his stay.
- Pizzas: Each pie is crafted with care, featuring a crispy crust and a delightful balance of toppings. The unique flavor combinations make for an exciting culinary adventure.
- Pasta Dishes: Reino’s excels in creamy fettuccine Alfredo and hearty lasagna, echoing the spirits of classic Italian cuisine. Mary E. vividly describes the dishes as "Yum Yum," expressing the joy they bring.
- Appetizers: Don’t miss the cheesy garlic bread, a crowd favorite, perfectly paired with a warm dipping sauce.
The atmosphere at Reino’s Pizza & Pasta is both casual and inviting—ideal for families and large groups. The upbeat ambiance often features the sounds of laughter and chatter, contributing to a lively dining scene. While dining, you might even catch a glimpse of the owner, Johnny Reino, innovatively preparing pizzas in the open kitchen, enhancing your connection to the culinary experience.
What’s more, Reino’s is thoughtfully designed to accommodate a variety of diners. They proudly offer delivery and takeout options, making it convenient for you to enjoy their delicious food anywhere. With multiple vegetarian options available and facilities such as outdoor seating and a full bar, it’s a great choice for all occasions. Plus, for those on the go, free Wi-Fi and ample bike parking make this spot even more appealing.
Whether you are local or just passing through, Reino’s Pizza & Pasta is a must-visit. Engage with expertly crafted dishes, relish the traditional flavors, and enjoy the welcoming vibe that makes it a standout in Tiffin’s food scene. Each visit feels like a special occasion, promising satisfying meals that leave diners yearning to revisit time and again.
Do yourself a favor—swing by Reino’s Pizza & Pasta and experience the delightful tastes and warm atmosphere that have made it a beloved gem in the community!
Nice little Italian place. Stopped in for dinner for night 1 of my 10 night stay in Tippin. I tried a small thin crust pizza of their own design (can remember the name). It was very good and the service was excellent. I will definitely return between now and night 10.
Yum! I love Renos food! The pizza, the pasta, the salad, whatever suits your fancy. You can have your pasta, plain sauce, meat, sauce, meatballs, and sauce, sausage and sauce, and of course, lasagna. If you like fettuccine, you can have that Alfredo sauce. Yum Yum. Good in the mouth and over the tongue and down the throat and in the tummy. Yum Yum yummy.
Clean, quaint, and delicious. The three words above pretty much sums it up. The food portions are generous, and the environment was great - even though I did a quick pick-up. The menu is extensive with plenty of options. I was amazed at how fresh and hot our meals were. If you are in the mood for some great Italian, put an order in and give it a go.
Food is good! I had cheesy garlic bread. It could have had more garlic flavor to it but the bread was very good and a nice amount of cheese. The sauce with it was good and warm. My pizza was good. A nice crust to it. They could be a little more generous with toppings. Price for pizza was good, garlic bread I thought was over priced. The service was great and very attentive.
Quaint small Italian spot nestled in downtown Tiffin. Our server, from Turkey, was an absolute delight. Always smiling, always pleasant, and calm for having a full place. She was a great representative of this nice spot. Our salads were on point, and our slice, was excellent. We'll be back for sure!! Holy Moly, back for SURE!
Best Italian joint in the Tiffin area. I always look for the coupons in the saver insert that gets delivered a few times a year. This place has the best Italian food hands-down. So many options I enjoy, but my go-to is the Alfredo....the sauce is perfect.
This place is killer. Super old school vibe with a family tradition. We got a small nabolidon with beef pep and banana peppers.... Fuckin delish This place is 10/10 AND they have a full bar. I mean, c'mon. Shook hands with Johnny Reino - he was in there busting his ass making pizzas - it was beautiful. Great vibes, great food. I wish I took a pic of the pizza but I ate it instead. It was a thing of beauty.
My cousin and I stopped here and were very pleased with the friendly bar maid/waitress named Olivia! She was very courteous, fast and very engaging! The pizza was amazing, the place was clean and organized! Excellent place to eat in Tiffin, Ohio! Nancy & Brenda
A gem of a place in downtown Tiffin! Came here with my fiancé and we tried the Philly sub, fettuccini Alfredo lunch special (comes with a side salad), and a slice of their classic pepperoni pizza. The pasta was baked with SO MUCH GOOEY CHEESE and absolutely bubbling when it came out so if you're a big baked pasta/cheese fan you will love it! The pizza reminded me of a Costco slice with the thicker bread, generous amounts of cheese, and classic marinara sauce. The standout of the meal however was the SUB! It is generously sauced, served crispy with piping hot filling, and seasoned perfectly!! One of the best subs I've ever had for sure, and found in a small town in Ohio! Highly recommend a visit here if you find yourself in Tiffin. I am not a local so I spent my time here on the hunt for good local eats and was not disappointed here. The interior ambience is super cute as well, and staff are extremely friendly and attentive.
My son just started school at Heidelberg and was so glad to find this place. Ate there twice so far and it definitely won't be our last. Already to him he has to bring lasagna back when he comes home... other favorites so far are the Alfredo with scallops and a pizza foldover. Younger son loves the pizza!! Great local restaurant.